The price of tin fell by more than 10% in a week. Is there suddenly no shortage of tin in the world?

Wanlian Wanxiang

2026.11.21 13:05

· From Beijing

Full text 3506 words

Text | Wanlian Wanxiang

AI data centers are still expanding and the semiconductor industry continues to develop, but tin prices have fallen by more than 10% in the past week.

From November 13 to 20, the average spot price of No. 1 tin in Shanghai Nonferrous Metals Network (SMM) fell from 359,300 yuan/ton to 321,500 yuan/ton, a cumulative decrease of 10.5%. On November 20, the Shanghai Tin SN2612 contract closed at 319,000 yuan/ton, down 3.61%. Previously, three-month tin on the London Metal Exchange (LME) had fallen below $42,000 per ton.

The decline comes as global tin inventories remain low. In the past few months, the slow resumption of production in Myanmar mines, restrictions on Indonesian exports, and the expected growth in demand brought by the AI ​​industry have been important factors supporting tin prices.

Just as the market is reassessing the outlook for global tin supply and demand, new mining policy news has come out of Indonesia, an important tin producer, adding uncertainty to future supply.

Does the continued decline in tin prices mean that global tin supply is turning loose, or is the market's previous concerns about future shortages priced too high?

Indonesia’s new policy increases mining investment variables

The lower tin prices come as Indonesian mining companies wait for the government to clarify a new revenue distribution requirement.

On November 20, Reuters quoted a report from the research institution CreditSights as pointing out that Indonesia's requirement to increase the share of national mining revenue and the arrangement of new verification fees for the export of some commodities may increase the cost pressure on local mining companies.

Previously, on November 14, Indonesian President Prabowo proposed that the country should obtain at least 70% of the income from operating activities related to mining licenses, and if necessary, it can obtain equity in mining companies.

The controversy lies in how to calculate this 70% income? Is it sales revenue, net profit, or the comprehensive economic benefits obtained by the government through taxes, royalties, etc.? Different explanations have completely different impacts on mining companies’ operations and investment returns.

Indonesian mining companies are still waiting for policy details. Fauzan Luthfi Djamal, a mining analyst at local Mirae Asset Sekuritas, believes that even uncertainty over the definition of rules could delay new investment decisions.

For mining companies, a new mine usually requires many years of investment from exploration, construction to stable production. Companies not only have to predict future metal prices, but also calculate taxes, financing costs and profit distribution. If these conditions are difficult to clarify, investment may be put on hold even if resources are available.

Indonesia has continued to strengthen mining supervision in recent years. Starting from 2026, the mining work plan and budget approval system (RKAB) will be readjusted to a one-year period, and companies will need to apply for production plans more frequently. This helps the government strengthen resource management and also makes the production arrangements of mining companies more dependent on the approval progress.

However, this time the 70% revenue requirement applies to the entire mining industry in Indonesia and is not specifically targeted at tin mines. As the specific implementation details have not yet been clarified, its actual impact on the operating costs and future investment of tin mining companies remains to be seen.

Compared with short-term production changes, Indonesian policy uncertainty is more likely to affect the medium- and long-term investment decisions of mining companies. The current supply changes in the tin market mainly come from the gradual recovery of previously restricted production capacity.

Some production capacity has been restored and supply constraints have eased.

Previously, Myanmar mines were slow to resume production, Indonesian exports were restricted, and some domestic mines and smelters also reduced production due to safety rectification and equipment maintenance. These factors, coupled with low inventories, once intensified concerns about insufficient supply.

But starting from the end of October, domestic production gradually resumed.

Yunnan Tin Co., Ltd. had previously arranged for the Gejiu smelting plant to undergo maintenance starting from September 30. SMM disclosed that the maintenance ended on October 26, and some other smelting companies have also resumed production.

In the week ending November 6, the operating rate of sample refined tin smelting enterprises in Yunnan and Jiangxi rose to 59.67%, an increase of 32.75 percentage points from the previous week. Part of the production capacity that had been restricted due to centralized maintenance began to be released again.

In terms of mining, Yinman Mining, a subsidiary of Industrial Silver Tin, also resumed underground mining production on October 30. Previously affected by the suspension of production and rectification after the safety accident, the company's mined tin output in the third quarter was only 572.22 tons, a decrease of 71.12% from the previous quarter. As production resumes, some of the previously restricted supply is expected to be gradually restored.

Improvements in output were also seen overseas. The refined tin output of Peruvian mining company Minsur's Pisco smelter in the third quarter reached 9,028 tons, a month-on-month increase of 28.35%. The overseas quarterly report of West China Securities on November 16 showed that the growth mainly came from the improvement of San Rafael mine output and the entry of previously accumulated concentrate stocks into the smelting process.

These changes illustrate that the restoration of refined tin supply does not necessarily require the commissioning of new mines. The resumption of operations of existing mines, the completion of maintenance of smelters or the consumption of raw material inventories may increase production in the near future. However, the relevant data involve different production links and statistical periods and cannot be directly added up to global new tin ore production.

However, the recovery of global tin supply has been uneven. China's imports of tin ore and concentrate from Myanmar fell by 25.55% month-on-month in September, and local mine supply has not yet recovered steadily. In Indonesia, SMM predicted at the Shanghai Metal Week meeting on November 17 that the country's tin ingot exports will remain at around 3,800 to 4,000 tons per month in the fourth quarter, indicating that export supply continues to be released.

From this point of view, global tin supply has not yet fully turned loose, but the restoration of some restricted production capacity is easing the previous tense situation.

AI investment expands, but global tin consumption may decline

Over the past year, tin has become one of the industrial metals that has received attention amid the AI ​​investment boom.

From server motherboards to semiconductor packages, a large number of electronic components are connected using tin-based solder. As technology companies increase investment in data centers, the market expects that the output of related equipment will expand, which will continue to drive tin consumption.

But in November, AI-related stocks suffered a sell-off, and tin prices were also affected.

However, the investment enthusiasm in the AI ​​industry has not yet been fully translated into actual tin consumption. On November 6, Tom Langston, senior market analyst at the International Tin Association (ITA), believed that AI data centers are an important growth driver of long-term demand for tin, but the more obvious impact of AI on the tin market this year comes from investor sentiment rather than an increase in actual consumption.

On the same day, the International Tin Industry Association released the "2026 Tin Consumption Study", which predicts that global refined tin usage will decrease by 2.2% year-on-year in 2026. The previous usage in 2025 was estimated to decrease by 1.3%. If forecasts come true, global tin consumption will decline for the second consecutive year.

AI investment continues to expand, why might global tin consumption decrease?

The reason is that AI is only a part of tin consumption. Traditional consumer electronics, automobiles, industrial equipment and photovoltaic industries also need tin. Even if demand related to AI servers increases, it may be offset by weak performance in other fields.

The International Tin Association pointed out that the slowdown in China's photovoltaic market, weak macroeconomics, and the financial pressure brought by previously high tin prices on downstream companies are important factors that will put pressure on tin consumption in 2026.

Furthermore, data center investments do not immediately translate into tin purchases. Equipment production and delivery take time, and the actual amount of tin used also depends on the number of servers, component structure and welding process, and cannot be simply calculated based on capital expenditures.

For investors, AI represents room for growth in the next few years; but for solder companies, actual orders still determine the scale of raw material procurement.

The logic of long-term demand for AI has not disappeared, but the premium the market was previously willing to pay for forward growth is being tested by actual consumption data.

Inventory recovery coupled with weak demand weakens tin price support

Demand growth is less than expected, which has been reflected in the domestic spot market.

SMM data shows that the operating rate of domestic solder companies in October was 76%, a decrease of 3.1 percentage points from the previous month. As the traditional electronics manufacturing peak season ends, some downstream companies have become cautious in purchasing.

However, after tin prices fell sharply on November 20, spot transactions improved. SMM midday review shows that some downstream companies have begun to purchase in batches, and smelters have loosened their stance on price support, but terminal orders have not increased significantly.

For solder companies, this is not a contradiction. When prices are high, companies may reduce stocking and prioritize inventory consumption; after prices fall, some buyers replenish raw materials. The increase in phased purchases does not mean that terminal consumption has resumed growth.

What deserves more attention than the purchasing rhythm is the changes in inventory and spot premium.

SMM data shows that in the week ending November 13, China’s social inventory of tin ingots increased by 502 tons to 5,673 tons, ending the previous five consecutive weeks of decline.

The changes in the LME market are even more obvious. On November 16, the premium of tin spot relative to the three-month futures once reached US$687.01/ton, and then narrowed rapidly, falling to US$155.04/ton by the morning of November 20.

The backwardation reflects the extra price the market pays to obtain the metal immediately. The rapid decline in premiums indicates that the previously prominent tightness of spot futures sources has eased.

However, premiums are still positive and global tin inventories have not accumulated significantly. What the market is currently facing is not a sudden abundance of inventory, but a short-term supply shortage that is not as tight as previously expected.

When some production capacity recovers, downstream procurement is weak, and the market begins to lower its expectations for forward demand for AI, tin prices may adjust significantly even if inventories remain low. Changes in macro risk appetite and capital transactions may amplify short-term fluctuations.

After this round of decline, the global tin market is still facing two different cycles of changes.

In the short term, the restoration of existing production capacity and weak actual consumption are weakening price support; in the medium and long term, the production policies of major resource countries such as Indonesia and Myanmar, as well as the implementation of new mine investments, will still affect future supply.

If demand from the electronics industry continues to be weak and existing production capacity continues to recover, the tin market may become looser. Conversely, if demand for AI, semiconductors and automotive electronics gradually increases, but new mines fail to release output in time, supply constraints may still reappear.

The price of tin has fallen by more than 10% in the past week, which does not prove that there is no shortage of tin in the world. It shows that the price that the market was previously willing to pay for tight supply and growing AI demand is being re-examined by the recovery of actual consumption and supply.

Whether the tin market can tighten again in the future depends on the speed difference between real consumption growth and the release of mine supply.

Information source description: International Tin Industry Association's "Tin Use Study 2026"; Reuters' tin market analysis on November 6 and Indonesian mining reports on November 18 and 20; SMM tin market conditions, inventory and smelting start-up data; related research reports of Guojin Securities, China Merchants Securities, and West China Securities.

Disclaimer: This article is for industrial research and market information exchange only and does not constitute any investment advice.

Respect for the original work, if you are qualified, you should be appreciated.

According to the real-name requirement of the Cybersecurity Law, please bind your mobile phone number before posting a comment.

Express

12:57

People in many European countries went on strike, affecting transportation and other public services.

12:51

Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs: Heads of State diplomacy plays a special leading role in Russia-China relations

12:40

Hongmeng Smart Xingjie V8 is launched, priced from 319,800 to 429,800 yuan

12:38

Argentine government approves country’s largest investment project

12:36

CITIC Securities: It is expected that a national mechanism electricity price policy will be launched in 2027

12:15

Bitcoin fell below $56,000, down more than 6% on the day

12:05

The National Development and Reform Commission held a video conference to supervise the payment and use of government investment funds and project reserve work

11:44

Bitcoin falls below $57,000, hitting lowest level since September 2024

11:36

The Mongolian section of Hanoi has entered the cold flood season from 2026 to 2027

11:11

SoftBank’s Masayoshi Son discussed acquiring SK Hynix for US$1 trillion

11:05

U.S. cargo Dragon spacecraft breaks away from the space station and sets off for return to Earth

10:31

U.S. presidential envoy discusses U.S.-Iran mediation work with senior Qatari officials

10:30

Quantum computer "high-speed memory" is realized on a real machine for the first time in the world

10:27

Agency: Demand has cooled, and prices for TVs, monitors and laptop panels may remain flat across the board in November.

10:25

Ming-Chi Kuo: Google is expected to adjust the shipment proportion of TPU 8t and 8i series in 2027

10:22

The phased adjustment has not changed the background, and many institutions are optimistic about the valuation and resilience of A-shares.

10:21

It is reported on the Internet that the trunk of Leipao A10 was crushed by several boxes of beer. Leapao responded.

10:19

International gold prices continue to decline

10:16

Federal Reserve official Paulson: Supports prudent interest rate hikes and can continue to raise interest rates if necessary

10:15

If the sale to SoftBank cannot be completed, ABB is reported to be considering spinning off its robotics business.

Scan to download App