Image source: Reuters

Warning: This report contains incidents of violence and sexual assault.

When Guan Young woke up to find herself tied to her bed, she knew nothing of the horrors she had been subjected to while unconscious.

After she heard her then-husband, Philip Young, telling someone else to "lower down," she quickly realized there was someone else in the bedroom with them.

Unbeknownst to Joan, Young was posting ads online inviting other men to assault her. Then he would drug her and bring strangers into their bedroom to sexually assault her.

This continued for 13 years.

On Thursday, four men were convicted of several crimes, including raping and assaulting Joan. Her ex-husband had already pleaded guilty to several rape crimes.

Young, a former Conservative local councillor, and another man named Dean Hamilton, pleaded guilty to rape and sexual assault during a previous hearing.

These men come from different backgrounds, with one working on nuclear defense projects for the Ministry of Defence, while another drove Red Cross trucks to Romania in the 1980s.

Joan's case has striking similarities to the repeated rape of Giselle Bellicot in France, with experts describing the crime as involving "extreme abuse".

The story of a woman who was sexually assaulted in the Middle Ages and the secrets of her legal battle to seek justice

A woman accuses Mohamed Al Fayed's brother of drugging and sexually assaulting her in Scotland

Image source: Swindon Advertiser

Young portrayed cyberbullying as an unconventional sexual practice that a couple shares, known as "cooking" (one partner enjoying sex with another person).

Pictures used in ads posted on sites such as Craigslist and Grindr showed Joan motionless and tied to a bed.

James Foster, a specialist prosecutor at the Crown Prosecution Service, said Young "was drugging her so that he could sexually assault her and film those assaults, as well as arranging for other men to come to the house to sexually assault her."

Among the men who responded to the ad was Dean Hamilton, 46, who admitted raping and assaulting Joanne in 2015.

The other men convicted of sexually assaulting Joan were Connor Sanderson Doyle, 32, Richard Wilkins, 62, Norman McSone, 48, and Mohamed Hassan, 38, the man Young told to “low down” when Joan woke up.

They told the court that they believed they had consent from both Joan and Young, and that they were told that she was pretending to be asleep, when in fact she was under the influence of strong doses of narcotic drugs.

“But not once during all of these assaults did they ask Joan Young what she wanted, nor did they show any interest in her wishes,” Foster said.

Image source: Wiltshire Police

The law states that consent to sexual intercourse is only valid if the person in question “consents of his own volition...and has the freedom and capacity to make that decision.”

The guidance to investigators states that they must determine “what steps, if any, the suspect took to obtain the complainant’s consent.”

Professor Marianne Hester, emeritus professor at the University of Bristol, said Joan "clearly" did not have the ability to refuse, adding that "women cannot express their consent while sleeping."

She added: "The same applies when they are completely under the influence of drugs. They cannot make the decision to consent to sex."

Hester, who has spent years studying gender-based violence, said these issues raise broader questions about attitudes toward women and sex.

She added: "We have to question men and their way of thinking about what they consider acceptable in sex, and how they continue to normalize these acts, and how we continue to normalize all these highly harmful practices within the framework of sexual relations, and this is a real problem."

Hester continued: “We know that investigations have already been launched into certain websites, and that people have been identified in a number of different countries who were engaging in very similar actions.”

“So I think there are a large number of similar issues that may unfold later,” she said.

Image source: Manon Cruz/REUTERS

The case also raised questions about the role of websites used to facilitate attacks.

Lisa Sugiura, professor of cybercrime and gender at the University of Portsmouth, said that online platforms have a responsibility to address content that normalizes violence against women.

She added: "These sites often witness, primarily, attacks based on the use of images, language and rhetoric characterized by extreme violence towards women."

She continued: “One wonders: How are these forums allowed to operate with impunity, without oversight or accountability?”

"And that's before we even get to the question of whether we should simply take the word of a man who claims to speak for himself and his wife."

The data shows that authorities are currently investigating hundreds of similar potential crimes across the UK.

The National Crime Agency said there was an "urgent need" to deal with the problem as an international issue.

Agency investigators identified more than 270 people linked to one of the online forums and the groups that emerged behind it.

The Royal Prosecution Service describes this type of crime as a new challenge for investigators.

Foster said: “It appears that this particular type of crime, in which the husband deliberately drugs and assaults his wife and arranges for other men to assault her, is a new type of crime.”

But Sugiura disagrees that these crimes are new in themselves.

She believes that technology has made it easier to commit and conceal attacks that may have existed for years.

She said: "The use of technology allows one to hide one's identity, separate two identities, and maintain a respectable image in real life, while these heinous acts are committed online."

She added that the perpetrators of these crimes are often active within broader online communities, where misogynistic attitudes are encouraged and offensive content is exchanged.

“These are not always isolated incidents,” she said.

She added: "You may be part of broader networks in which members exchange advice, encourage each other, and share material that is extremely offensive to women."

She continued: “I think there are a large number of similar issues that may unfold later.”

Find out more

Short clips

End of short clips

Main news

Saudi Arabia announces the interception of new ballistic missiles launched by the Houthis towards Riyadh

How did a husband drug his wife and subject her to rape by strangers over a period of 13 years?

“The far right threatens Europe, but it is fragile” - article in The Guardian

We chose for you

Readers' preferences