image copyrightReuters
The possibility of a North Korea-US summit has been discussed ahead of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit to be held in Shenzhen, China on the 18th, but no specific moves to support this have been confirmed.
The United States officially announced the schedule for the first trilateral summit between President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin, but announced that it had no plans for contact with North Korea.
Until recently, some U.S. Korean Peninsula experts predicted that President Trump, who lost in the midterm elections, could push for a meeting with Chairman Kim at APEC for diplomatic results.
However, prior coordination for the actual summit has not been publicly confirmed, and weight is being given to the analysis that North Korea will not benefit from immediate dialogue.
image copyrightEPA/Shutterstock
US-China-Russia talks confirmed... There are no plans to contact North America
The White House announced on the 13th (local time) that President Trump, President Xi, and President Putin will hold a trilateral summit in Shenzhen on the 19th.
However, a senior U.S. government official announced on the same day that there were no plans to contact North Korea during President Trump's Asia trip.
Nuclear disarmament issues are scheduled to be discussed at the U.S.-China-Russia talks, but it has not been disclosed whether the North Korean nuclear issue has been included in the formal agenda.
However, as there are speculations that President Trump may request cooperation from China and Russia to resume North Korea-US dialogue, attention is also focused on the possibility that Korean Peninsula issues will be discussed without Korea participating.
End of TOP News
At a recent meeting between the foreign ministers of Korea and China, the Korean government conveyed its position that issues on the Korean Peninsula should not be decided by agreement between major powers without Korea's interests being excluded. The purpose is that a situation reminiscent of the 1945 Yalta Conference, where powerful countries discussed the post-war international order, should not be repeated.
In the meantime, President Trump has shown interest in resuming North Korea-US dialogue by showing off his close relationship with Chairman Kim. He told reporters at the White House on September 29, “Kim Jong-un is my friend,” and “He likes me, and I like him.”
Victor Cha, Korea Chair at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), also assessed that the possibility of a meeting between the two leaders has increased after the midterm elections on the 9th. The explanation is that President Trump, who has suffered a political blow, may seek diplomatic results, and North Korea may view the weakened President Trump as an easy partner to negotiate with.
However, there appears to be no progress in the behind-the-scenes negotiations or working-level contacts necessary to promote the summit. It is said that the United States previously sought dialogue with North Korea, but did not receive a response from North Korea.
Meanwhile, North Korea is continuing high-level diplomacy toward China and Russia. Following the visit of Labor Party International Secretary Kim Seong-nam to China earlier this month, Chairman Kim's closest close associate Cho Yong-won, Secretary of the Workers' Party of Korea, also visited Russia on the 14th.
‘Agreement comes before meeting’
Past meetings between President Trump and Chairman Kim took place after long-term preliminary contact.
Ahead of the first summit in 2018, then-US Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) Director Mike Pompeo visited Pyongyang, and then-North Korean Workers' Party Vice Chairman Kim Yong-chol visited the White House with a personal letter from Chairman Kim. An exchange of personal letters and working-level negotiations between the leaders continued.
Despite that process, the Hanoi summit in February 2019 ended without an agreement. North Korea requested sanctions relief, suggesting the dismantlement of the Yongbyon nuclear facility, but was unable to narrow differences with the United States over the scope of denuclearization measures and sanctions relief.
Chairman Kim traveled directly to Vietnam, but did not achieve the results he expected. It has been experienced that the outcome of negotiations cannot be guaranteed solely through friendship or symbolic meetings between the leaders. This time, no concrete preparations for the summit, such as special envoy visits or working-level negotiations, have been publicly confirmed.
Although the possibility of a private meeting cannot be ruled out, the analysis is that it is difficult for North Korea to readily respond to an unprepared surprise meeting as it must consider the results after the meeting and Kim Jong-un's political status.
Lim Chul, a professor at Kyungnam University's Institute for Far Eastern Studies, told the BBC, "North Korea carefully calculates what impact a summit meeting will have on the performance and status of its supreme leader. It is absurd to bring up the possibility of a summit in a situation where there is no prior coordination."
Sanctions relief and nuclear issues
The key stumbling block in dialogue between North Korea and the United States remains the issue of North Korea's nuclear weapons and sanctions against North Korea.
In September of last year, Chairman Kim stated that he would be open to dialogue if the United States withdrew its demand for denuclearization and acknowledged that North Korea possesses nuclear weapons.
On the other hand, the United States does not officially recognize North Korea as a nuclear state.
Sanctions relief is an important economic benefit that North Korea can gain through improved relations with the United States. According to the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), North Korea's trade with China has recovered but remains below pre-2018 levels. Despite expanding cooperation with Russia and recovering trade with China, restrictions on international finance and external transactions still remain.
In this situation, Chairman Kim made it clear in his speech last year that he would not negotiate to exchange nuclear weapons for sanctions relief.
It is also difficult for the United States to ease sanctions without substantial progress on North Korea's nuclear issue. Even if the two sides hold a summit, it is not easy to agree on what to exchange.
Democratic Party takes control of Congress... As a variable in North American negotiations
The results of the U.S. midterm elections are making the calculations of both sides surrounding the North Korea-U.S. summit more complicated. For President Trump, who has faced increasing restrictions in domestic politics due to the Democratic Party's control of the Senate and House of Representatives, dialogue between North Korea and the United States could be a diplomatic breakthrough. On the other hand, for Chairman Kim, it is a factor that increases uncertainty about whether the agreement between the leaders can actually be implemented.
The Democratic Party secured majority positions in the Senate and House of Representatives in the midterm elections on the 3rd. The new parliament will be launched in January next year.
The president has the authority to suspend or waive some sanctions against North Korea, but must meet the requirements of relevant laws and notify Congress. The issue of broadly lifting UN sanctions cannot be solved solely by the decision of the US president.
This means that even if President Trump agrees to adjust joint ROK-US joint exercises or ease sanctions against North Korea, there may be checks from Congress and concerns from allies.
The dispute between North Korea and the United States surrounding the recent large-scale virtual asset hacking incident may also put a strain on the atmosphere of dialogue. The United States pointed out North Korea as the mastermind behind the Binance virtual asset theft incident, and Labor Party Director Kim Yo-jong protested, calling it a political provocation. The U.S. Department of Justice announced on the 12th that more than $2.7 billion (about 3.6 trillion won) worth of virtual assets were frozen through cooperation between the government and the private sector.
As the conditions for negotiations between North Korea and the United States and the political situation in the United States intersect, it appears that it will be difficult for a summit to be held within this year at least.
Nam Sung-wook, a professor at Sookmyung Women's University, said, "It appears that this year's North Korea-U.S. summit has virtually passed the water," and predicted that the summit will only be possible if an atmosphere for dialogue is established next year.




