image copyrightGetty Images

This year’s Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Leaders’ Informal Meeting will be held in Shenzhen. U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin are all expected to attend. Whether the leaders of the three countries will take this opportunity to hold their first formal trilateral talks has become the biggest suspense of this summit.

In addition, with the ongoing wars in Iran and Ukraine and the turmoil in global energy politics, whether leaders of powerful countries will touch on security issues in this economic-centered occasion has also attracted much attention.

Another focus is Japanese Prime Minister Takaichi Sanae. Sino-Japanese relations have reached a freezing point due to the "Taiwan incident" remarks. Whether she can formally meet with Xi Jinping during this trip, or even exchange a handshake, has become a weather vane for observing the relationship between the two countries.

At a sustainable development summit held at the University of Hong Kong a few days ago, BBC Chinese conducted an exclusive interview with Eduardo Pedrosa, Executive Director of the APEC Secretariat. He repeatedly emphasized in the interview that APEC is not a place to sign agreements, nor is it a mechanism designed to solve hard geopolitical issues, but a platform for the exchange of opinions: under a non-binding framework, economies with huge differences can still sit at the same table to discuss how to make the systems operate with each other, and "each other can hear each other's voices."

The United States, China and Russia are present together: the suspense of trilateral talks

Whether the Shenzhen APEC Summit can lead to the first formal meeting between the leaders of the United States, China and Russia is the most watched issue of this session.

Trump told reporters on November 8 that he believed he would meet with Xi Jinping and Putin in Shenzhen to discuss issues such as "denuclearization" and ending the war with Iran.

Beijing's attitude is relatively reserved. Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Mao Ning said earlier that China is maintaining communication with relevant parties on the meeting of the three heads of state, but did not explicitly promise that the meeting will definitely take place. According to media reports such as the Financial Times, officials from the three countries have launched serious consultations on the matter, but there are still differences in the content of the agenda: Trump prefers to focus on nuclear arms control and Iran, Putin hopes to use this to discuss a ceasefire in Ukraine, and China has a cold attitude towards discussing the Ukrainian issue without European participation.

Analysts pointed out that if the meeting comes true, it will be a diplomatic breakthrough for Moscow; Beijing appears to be more cautious and may value the symbolic meaning of the meeting more than the actual results.

End of Hot Reading

In this regard, Pedrosa told the BBC that it is impossible to predict the possibility of the leaders of the three countries meeting in Shenzhen; even if it takes place, it is impossible to predict what the talks will be and what the results will be, but this is the characteristic of APEC's openness. Since APEC is a non-binding organization, members can exchange views on sensitive issues, but he reiterated that APEC still focuses on economic development.

"APEC is a very useful venue because we focus on economic policy issues... In addition to plenary discussions, it also provides opportunities for leaders to hold talks outside the meeting. You may see any number of bilateral, trilateral or multilateral discussions taking place outside the meeting," Pedrosa said.

He emphasized that what is special about APEC is that it brings other economies into the dialogue: "These three major countries can meet anywhere, but APEC is unique because each member has its own voice and agency."

image copyrightAFP via Getty Images

Sanae Takaichi’s trip to China: The weight of a handshake

It is generally analyzed by the outside world that the possibility of a formal meeting between Sanae Takaichi and Xi Jinping in Shenzhen is extremely low. The two sides have reached a deadlock over Gao Shi's "Taiwan is having trouble" remarks in November last year. China has demanded that she withdraw the relevant statement, but she has not backed down so far.

Kyodo News and other Japanese media reported that there has been little progress in the coordination of formal APEC talks between China and Japan. Some Chinese sources even said that Japan may be the only country among the major participating countries that cannot hold bilateral talks with Xi Jinping.

Although the chance of summit dialogue is slim, Japan still has clear strategic goals. "Nihon Keizai Shimbun" reported that the Japanese government plans to push for the inclusion of "trade transparency" in the leader's declaration, emphasizing the importance of transparency in response to measures that may disrupt the supply chain, clearly taking China's rare earth export controls and overcapacity into consideration. China has prioritized "opening up" this year, and Tokyo is trying to use this to counter unilateral economic measures within a multilateral framework.

Bloomberg reported on the 9th that Japanese officials have sought assurances from China, hoping that Xi Jinping will give Takayama the same courtesy as other leaders, and at least shake hands as usual; if there are abnormal arrangements, Japan will protest.

When responding to relevant questions on the 11th, the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs did not take a positive position. It only reiterated that "it has stated its position on Sino-Japanese relations many times" and emphasized that China will fulfill its obligations as the host. China's state-run Global Times published an article on Tuesday, describing Japan's concerns as a typical "guilty conscience" style of diplomacy, criticizing Tokyo that what it should really worry about is not the opportunity to shake hands or the opportunity to take a photo, but that wrong policies continue to overwhelm the trust of neighboring countries and make its own diplomatic path narrower and narrower.

In addition, Chen Yang, a researcher at the China Charhar Society, told Singapore's Lianhe Zaobao that although Gao Shi is visiting China for the first time since taking office, it does not mean that Beijing will dilute its principled stance; polite contacts, handshakes or brief exchanges are still possible. Lin Dawei, a professor at Japan's Soka University, also pointed out to the newspaper that Takaichi's trip still has symbolic significance: Northeast Asia is a high-context culture, and every brief meeting may improve the atmosphere and create conditions for the gradual progress of relations.

At the same time, the Mainichi Shimbun pointed out that Japan has conveyed to the United States its concerns about the trilateral talks between the United States, China and Russia. In particular, China and Russia have recently intensified military activities around Japan. The direction of nuclear arms control, Ukraine and Iran and other issues, as well as the impression that the United States is close to China and Russia, have made Tokyo particularly sensitive.

When interviewed, Pedrosa said that APEC could not predict whether Gao Shi would attend as scheduled and what he would say, but he hoped that the more people would participate, the better, so as to give full play to APEC's convening power. "Most leaders will want to attend. Sometimes domestic emergencies make them have to deal with other things, but people like to come to APEC. It's important for leaders to get together, and historically we've seen leaders make an effort to attend," he said.

Why did China choose Shenzhen?

Judging from the history of APEC, each host country will choose a city that can show its image to the world. Pedrosa explained to the BBC that last year South Korea chose Gyeongju, a UNESCO World Heritage city that was part of an ancient kingdom, because its owners wanted to showcase cultural heritage.

The core topic of APEC this year is technology and innovation. He believes that this may be one of the reasons why China chose Shenzhen.

"We are experiencing very rapid technological change, but are we ready? Is the workforce ready? It will change business models, affect the workforce, and some people will lose their jobs, but new jobs will be created. What we need to work together is skills improvement," he said.

image copyrightHKU Business School

APEC’s role in the energy and food crisis

When it comes to the global situation, Pedrosa repeatedly emphasized the uniqueness of APEC: consensus decision-making, member-driven, and non-binding, which allows for more honest dialogue among members. In the process leading up to the November leadership meeting, members have held approximately 14 ministerial meetings.

"For example, on trade issues, all parties have many different views on the current status of trade and the progress of trade policies, but we can still reach consensus on things that all APEC members believe are important to the future world economy. This is what makes APEC special and why this leaders' meeting is extremely important."

Feng Huilan, former executive vice president of the World Bank, also recently said at a symposium at the University of Hong Kong that precisely because APEC is informal and does not require the signing of a treaty, it allows more sensitive topics to be exchanged here. Pedrosa agreed: "APEC is called an informal forum and can indeed discuss sensitive issues."

He said that if you participate in these dialogues, you will see that sensitive issues do exist: "At the highest level, because we have a responsibility to our own people, it is really difficult; but at the same time we are also talking about very specific technical issues. This is where regulations and trade policies differ, and this is where the exchange of views is extremely important."

Pedrosa also did not shy away from challenges: "APEC cannot pretend that there are no challenges. We face higher oil prices and expect higher food prices for many reasons. But as far as APEC itself is concerned, we are quite unique: non-binding, voluntary, and have a vision to establish an open, dynamic, resilient and peaceful environment in a specific region. Every APEC host is working hard to contribute to the realization of this vision."

Explore more

More short films

More short films end

Before the APEC summit, a US think tank analyzes the details and limits of Sino-Russian military-industrial cooperation under "technological nationalism"

Four months before APEC, China’s Shenzhen subway suddenly tightened security checks, causing public complaints

The SCO summit follows the September 3rd military parade: Is the China-led anti-US alliance entering a new era?

After the murder of a Japanese school boy in Shenzhen, Chinese in Japan reflect on "Japanese-hating education"

The U.S., China and Russia compete for a world "dominated by strength, force and power"

China's smart cities are developing rapidly, but privacy and security are at a high cost

headlines

The White House confirms that Trump, Xi Jinping and Putin will hold a historic tripartite meeting during APEC in Shenzhen

Zelensky: The United States offers Ukraine to give up Donbass in exchange for joining NATO

Jen-Hsun Huang was summoned to attend a Senate hearing, and Commerce Secretary Lutnick was affected and must also testify

Special recommendation

Popular content