Image source: Getty Images

Which oil is better for cooking is often discussed in homes. This is a topic on which there is debate.

In recent times, we hear things like 'using coconut oil for cooking is beneficial for health'.

Coconut oil has been given a special place in diet plans like 'Keto and Paleo'.

Meanwhile, a study by the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) has sparked a new debate regarding the use of coconut oil and ghee.

According to this study, people who use coconut oil and ghee are more likely to have higher levels of LDL cholesterol than those who use peanut oil.

LDL (low-density lipoprotein) cholesterol is also called 'bad cholesterol'.

What does ICMR study say?

Data of 18,090 people included in the study of ICMR's Indian Diabetes Research Program 'ICMR-INDIAB' were analyzed.

In this study, information was taken from the participants about the type of oil used in cooking.

End

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

After this it was compared with other health parameters related to their cholesterol and metabolism.

Those who used peanut oil, compared to those who used other oils, were more likely to have higher LDL cholesterol as follows:

Describing this study, diabetologist Dr. Mohan says, "Many people say that coconut oil is very good and it increases lifespan. But there is no clear data available to support this claim."

He further says, "If we look at the recent ICMR-INDIAB study, the use of coconut oil is very low in Tamil Nadu, whereas its use is high in states like Kerala and Goa. The average cholesterol of the people there is 40 to 50 mg higher than that of the people of Tamil Nadu. A simple explanation for this could be coconut oil."

However, Dr. Mohan says, "I would not say that you should not eat coconut oil at all or that it is very dangerous. If you like coconut oil, then use it in small quantities."

Do ghee and coconut oil cause heart attacks?

Image source: DrArunkumar/Facebook

This study compares people's eating habits and their health-related parameters over a certain period of time.

This study points to a relationship. But this does not prove that any particular oil directly causes heart attacks.

Talking about this, doctor and nutrition consultant Arun Kumar says, "In this study, a survey of 14 questions was conducted on all the people. They were asked which oil they use, approximately how much quantity they use and whether they also eat outside food. After asking some such questions, they were tested for cholesterol once. Then based on their answers, the data was compared."

He says, "The only basis of this study is that among the people who have high cholesterol level, how many people use which oil. The most important thing in this research should have been to find out whether there is a reduction in the cases of heart attack or not. But this was not investigated in this study."

Saturated Fat in Coconut Oil and Ghee

We can generally divide the fats included in our food into two categories – saturated fat and unsaturated fat.

There are two types of unsaturated fat:

monounsaturated fat

polyunsaturated fat

Coconut oil, ghee, butter and palm oil have high amounts of saturated fat.

For example, ghee contains 60-65% saturated fat, 20-25% monounsaturated fat, 3-4% polyunsaturated fat and some vitamins.

Coconut oil is composed of 100% fat, of which 80-90% is saturated.

Some studies have confirmed that excessive consumption of saturated fat can increase LDL cholesterol levels.

"These saturated fats definitely have the potential to increase cholesterol," says Dr. Mohan.

They say that monounsaturated fat present in peanut oil and sesame oil is a better option.

He says, "Peanut oil comes first and then sesame oil comes second. Both of these mainly contain monounsaturated fat. It reduces bad cholesterol and increases good cholesterol i.e. HDL."

He further explains, "If you go to the northern and eastern parts of India, mustard oil is used there. It also has almost the same amount of monounsaturated fat as peanut oil. People use this oil there."

Similarly, "Sunflower oil and safflower oil fall into the category of polyunsaturated fats. There is no doubt that they reduce bad cholesterol."

'Coconut oil also increases good cholesterol'

Dr. Arun Kumar says, "Saturated fat can increase LDL slightly, but it can also have some other positive changes. It increases cholesterol slightly, but it also increases HDL i.e. good cholesterol."

He says, "Similarly, the short-chain fatty acids present in ghee provide some health benefits by getting absorbed in the stomach. Therefore, on the basis of a small increase in cholesterol alone, one should not conclude that it directly increases the risk of heart attack."

A study published in the journal 'Circulation' in 2020 combined analysis of the results of 16 clinical studies related to coconut oil.

It found that LDL cholesterol levels increased by an average of 10.47 mg/dL in those who used coconut oil compared to other vegetable oils. At the same time, the level of HDL cholesterol had increased by 4 mg/dL.

Similarly, a Cochrane review published in 2020 examined whether reducing saturated fat intake reduces the risk of heart disease.

In this review, data of more than 56,000 people from 15 studies was analyzed.

It found that reducing saturated fat intake reduced the incidence of total cardiovascular disease, including heart disease and stroke, by 17 percent. However, no significant change was seen in total mortality.

What is the importance of LDL cholesterol?

LDL is a type of lipoprotein particle that transports cholesterol in the blood to various cells of the body.

Cholesterol is essential for the functioning of our body cells. It is needed to make the outer membrane of cells and produce some hormones.

But when the amount of LDL particles in the blood becomes high, they can cause fatty deposits (plaques) in the walls of blood vessels. Due to this, the blood vessels become narrow and the blood flow to the heart can be affected.

Because of this the risk of heart attack and stroke increases.

A research report by the European Atherosclerosis Society published in the 'European Heart Journal' in 2017 confirmed the link between LDL cholesterol and cardiovascular diseases based on multiple lines of evidence.

Which oil is best to use for cooking?

According to the guidelines issued by the World Health Organization (WHO) in 2023, the amount of saturated fat in a person's total daily calories should not exceed 10 percent.

According to WHO, it is better to consume unsaturated fats found in fish, avocado, nuts, sunflower, soybean, canola and olive oil than saturated fats found in fatty meat, butter, coconut oil, ghee and animal fat.

Dr. Mohan says, "When purchasing oil, one can opt for peanut oil and sesame oil having monounsaturated fats. Also, it is important to use the oil in small quantities."

He further says, "Sunflower oil containing polyunsaturated fat can also be used as per the need. As far as possible, it is better to replace oils like palm oil with other alternatives."

Keep these things in mind while using oil

Dr. Mohan also advises that one should avoid excessive consumption of food items prepared in oil and heating and using the same oil again and again.

The National Institute of Nutrition, working under the Indian Council of Medical Research, also emphasizes this in its dietary guidelines.

He says, "Repeated heating of oil causes oxidation in it and compounds can be formed which can be harmful to the body. Therefore, use the oil only as per requirement and if any oil is left, throw it away."

Dr. Arun Kumar says that along with the choice of oil, we should also pay attention to our overall diet and lifestyle.

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

What does Nepal want from India, how much will Balen Shah be able to achieve?

Ghee, coconut or peanut oil, what is good for health - what experts are saying

LIVE: Drone attack on Russian cargo ship in Gulf of Finland, rescue operation underway

must read

most popular