To view this content from YouTube, it is necessary to allow the collection of viewing rates and YouTube ads.
It appears that an application in your internet browser is preventing the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must cancel its use.
Published on: 04/09/2026 - 17:54
Could the biography of the Prophet Muhammad be more complex than we think? Between faith and history, this debate raises a difficult question: Are we talking about the same Prophet when we read his biography as believers or as historians? In this episode, Salma Bonjara interviews researcher Hala Al-Wardi, who presents a critical and bold reading of the Prophet’s biography, and opens the door to questions that are rarely asked: Is it possible to study the Prophet Muhammad as a historical figure? Why are some questions about biography a “red line”? Who has the right to narrate the life of the Prophet? Does knowledge strengthen faith or threaten it? We then continue the discussion with Tariq Obero and Ahmed Makki about the limits of criticism, the sacred, and the complex relationship between religion and history.
The Prophet Muhammad: one personality...or multiple readings?
The biography of the Prophet Muhammad is considered one of the most influential in human history, not only because of its religious dimension, but also because it touches on areas of politics, society, and culture. However, this biography is not a single fixed text, but rather a historical construct formed through centuries of recording and interpretation.
This is what prompts a central question: Are we facing a single biography, or are we facing a plurality of readings?
Historical reading: when the historian enters the sacred area
In her latest book, Hala Al-Wardi proposes a critical approach to the biography of the Prophet, in which she attempts to reconstruct the character away from the traditional theistic reading. Between psychoanalysis and history: To what extent is interpretation possible?
One of the most prominent things that Al-Wardi proposes is a psychological reading of personality, linking the experience of early orphanhood to the building of a leadership personality later on.
But this type of analysis raises a double problem that the guests answer
Transformations in biography: between the social, the political, and the personal
Among the points that also raise discussion are the transformations that occurred in the life of the Prophet:
Specifically, the issue of marriage and its relationship with women is read in different ways
Here the importance of the question arises: Is it possible to separate the private from the political in a biography like this? Who has the right to narrate the biography?
Nigerian writer Chinua Achebe recalls a famous quote:
“As long as lions do not have their own historians, the history of the hunt will always glorify the hunter.”
This opens the door to a broader question:
We also raise the question of the limits of criticism, especially when it comes to a sacred figure.
Taboo: Why are some questions redlined?
There are points in the biography that are considered very sensitive, especially when read by contemporary standards, such as:
Here a clear tension appears: between historical understanding and modern moral criticism
The question is not just what is being said?
But also who determines what should not be said?
In the end, the discussion reaches a philosophical question:
Does knowledge weaken faith...or strengthen it?
Perhaps the answer does not lie in the choice between faith and knowledge, but rather in the ability to coexist between them without one canceling out the other, as Tariq Oubro explains.
Episode guests:
- Hala Al-Wardi, university professor and researcher at the Tunisian University and French universities - Paris - France
- Tariq Oubrou, Islamic thinker and imam of the Grand Mosque of Bordeaux - Bordeaux - France
- Sheikh Ahmed Makki Al-Azhari, Azhari preacher - Cairo - Egypt
Related keywords
The content you want to browse is no longer in service or is currently unavailable.




