The last time the SEC investigated Huida, it was because the mining boom in 2017 pushed up gaming graphics card revenue, but the quarterly report was not clearly stated; five years later, Huida paid a settlement of US$5.5 million, and no executives were fined. A shareholder class action lawsuit has been going on for nearly eight years, and court records show the parties settled in principle in October for an undisclosed amount. (Previous summary: Reuters: SEC is investigating Huida for potential accounting issues, NVIDIA closed down 14% on Friday) (Background supplement: The court rejected Huida’s appeal” Nvidia concealed “miners’ income from buying GPUs exceeded 1 billion US dollars” securities fraud case resumed) The last time the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) investigated Huida, it was because of the mining boom in 2017: game display card revenue was pushed up by miners, but Huida’s quarterly report did not make it clear. The two parties settled in May 2022, and Huida paid a fine of US$5.5 million, neither admitting nor denying the SEC's findings. And this week the SEC came to Huida again. The Wall Street Journal reported that the SEC launched a civil investigation into Huida after Huang Renxun resigned as CEO in November; Reuters quoted two people who had been briefed on the investigation as saying that law enforcement officials were looking at potential accounting issues... Huida's stock price closed down 14% on November 20. What did the SEC think Huida failed to explain clearly? When Ethereum rose from less than $10 on New Year's Day in 2017 to nearly $800 within a year, miners rushed to buy Huida's gaming graphics cards for mining. The SEC's settlement order pointed out that Huida internally knew that the demand for gaming graphics cards had increased significantly, and a large part of it came from mining; in the second and third quarters of fiscal year 2018 (approximately equal to 2017), gaming revenue increased by 52% and 25% annually. However, Huida’s two quarterly reports in August and November 2017 did not mention that mining is an important factor in game revenue growth. What is even more misleading is that the same quarterly report states that mining is an important source of another product line, namely mining cards sold exclusively to mining farms. Comparing the two, readers would think that the gaming business is not affected much by mining. At that time, analysts and investors repeatedly asked how much of gaming revenue came from mining. It was not until the annual report at the end of February 2018 that Huida wrote it out. The SEC determined that Huida violated the anti-fraud provisions of the securities laws and the disclosure provisions of periodic reports and failed to maintain adequate disclosure control mechanisms. Among them, the anti-fraud provision is valid as long as there is negligence, and there is no need to prove intentionality. Huida agreed to accept the cease-and-desist order, promising not to violate it again, and pay $5.5 million within 14 days, or about 0.06% of the company's fiscal 2018 revenue of $9.714 billion. The SEC only punished the company and did not punish any individual executives. There is another clause in the settlement: in the lawsuit filed by investors for the same matter, Huida cannot claim to use this fine as a deduction for compensation. The shareholder lawsuit has been going on for almost 8 years, but what’s the result? On November 15, 2018, Huida’s financial report was not as good as expected. Colette Kress, then chief financial officer and now interim CEO, said that the channel inventory was digested slower than expected after the mining ebb. Huang Renxun called the excess inventory a “mining hangover.” The stock price fell 28.5% in two trading days. In December, investors filed a class action lawsuit in the Northern California Federal District Court, accusing Huida, Huang and others of downplaying the impact of mining on revenue. The plaintiffs point to Huang's November 2017 interview in which he said cryptocurrency "will always be small to us, probably $70 million." The plaintiff also cited estimates from Prysm Group, a consulting firm entrusted by the plaintiff, that from May 2017 to July 2018, approximately US$1.126 billion in mining-related revenue was included in gaming revenue but was not stated clearly; this is an estimate by the plaintiff, not a determination by the court or SEC. The District Court dismissed the case in March 2021. In August 2023, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals partially overturned 2 to 1, holding that the complaint was sufficient to claim that Huang may have knowingly or recklessly misled investors, but the charges against Kress and others were still dismissed. Huida appealed to the Supreme Court. In December 2024, the Supreme Court withdrew the case (holding that it should not have been accepted in the first place), and the case returned to the district court. In March 2026, the judge allowed the lawsuit to proceed as a class action. Investors who bought Huida’s shares from August 2017 to November 2018 were included. The only defendants were Huida and Huang Renxun. The trial was originally scheduled to open in September 2027. Court records show that on October 22, 2026, the two parties notified the court of a settlement in principle, before the Jen-Hsun Huang controversy broke out. The settlement amount was not disclosed, and the court gave both parties until November 25 to apply for preliminary approval. Comparing the two times, the reason last time was very specific: the quarterly report omitted to mention the impact of mining on game revenue. It took nearly 5 years from the problematic quarterly report to the settlement. This time, Reuters only said it was an accounting issue. The New York Times said it was still in the early stages. It remains to be seen whether there will be formal prosecution. Neither the SEC nor Huida has publicly responded to the investigation. Related reports Nvidia | Huida pays fine to settle SEC for not fully disclosing the impact of "cryptocurrency mining" on GPU sales in 18 years. Nvidia's stock price fell 54%. CEO Jensen Huang called it "the hangover period of the mining industry." Big news! Nvidia’s Jen-Hsun Huang resigned, Chief Financial Officer Colette Kress took over the helm of Huida. Big short-seller Michael Burry questioned Nvidia’s financial report: Why did 22% of Singapore’s revenue disappear out of thin air? 〈This is not the first time that the SEC has investigated Huida: the 2017 quarterly report did not include mining revenue. What happened next? 〉This article was first published in DongZu BlockTempo "DongZu DongTen - the most influential blockchain news media".
This is not the first time that the SEC has investigated Huida: the 2017 quarterly report did not include mining revenue. What happened next?
The last time the SEC investigated Huida, it was because the mining boom in 2017 pushed up gaming graphics card revenue, but the quarterly report did not clearly state it; five years later, Huida paid US$5.5 million […] This was not the first time that the SEC investigated Huida: the 2017 quarterly report did not include mining revenue. What happened next? 〉This article was first published in DongZu BlockTempo "DongZu DongTen - the most influential blockchain news media".

This article may contain an automated translation. The original source is linked for verification.


